tests/testplan_roadmap.md

# 🗺️ MMORPG Test Plan Roadmap

## 📊 Current Status Summary (June 8, 2025)

### ✅ **COMPLETED: Service Layer Unit Tests (159 tests, 100% pass rate)**

| Service | Test File | Tests | Status | Coverage Areas |
|---------|-----------|--------|--------|----------------|
| **ChatService** | `test_chat_service.py` | 43 | ✅ Complete | Messaging, plugins, NPC responses, history, filtering |
| **NPCService** | `test_npc_service_corrected.py` | 49 | ✅ Complete | Behaviors, movement, registration, integration |
| **PluginService** | `test_plugin_service_final.py` | 26 | ✅ Complete | Loading, lifecycle, dependencies, events, security |
| **MCPService** | `test_mcp_service_corrected.py` | 41 | ✅ Complete | AI agents, movement, chat, game state, entities |

**Achievement**: All four main service layer components now have comprehensive, fully functional test suites.

---

## 🎯 **NEXT PHASE: Advanced Testing Implementation**

### 1. 🔗 **Integration Testing** - **PRIORITY: HIGH**
**Objective**: Test cross-service interaction and data flow

#### 1.1 Service-to-Service Integration Tests
**Target File**: `tests/integration/test_service_integration.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 25-30 tests

**Test Areas**:
- **ChatService ↔ NPCService**: NPC response generation and delivery
- **ChatService ↔ PluginService**: Plugin command processing and responses
- **MCPService ↔ NPCService**: AI agent interaction with NPCs
- **MCPService ↔ ChatService**: AI agent chat message handling
- **PluginService ↔ All Services**: Plugin event broadcasting and handling
- **PlayerService ↔ All Services**: Player state synchronization

**Key Scenarios**:
```python

def test_npc_chat_integration():

    """Test complete NPC conversation flow"""

    # Player sends message → ChatService → NPCService → response generation → delivery



def test_mcp_agent_npc_interaction():

    """Test AI agent interacting with NPC"""

    # MCP agent → NPCService → behavior handling → response → MCPService



def test_plugin_command_processing():

    """Test plugin command flow"""

    # Chat command → PluginService → command execution → ChatService response

```

#### 1.2 Database Integration Tests
**Target File**: `tests/integration/test_database_integration.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 15-20 tests

**Test Areas**:
- Chat message persistence and retrieval
- Player data consistency across services
- NPC state persistence
- Transaction handling and rollback scenarios

#### 1.3 Real-time Update Integration
**Target File**: `tests/integration/test_realtime_integration.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 10-15 tests

**Test Areas**:
- WebSocket message broadcasting
- Multi-client synchronization
- Real-time position updates
- Chat message delivery timing

---

### 2. 🎭 **End-to-End Testing** - **PRIORITY: HIGH**
**Objective**: Complete workflow validation from user perspective

#### 2.1 Player Journey Tests
**Target File**: `tests/e2e/test_player_journey.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 20-25 tests

**Test Scenarios**:
- **New Player Onboarding**: Registration → world entry → first interactions
- **Basic Gameplay**: Movement → NPC interaction → chat participation
- **Advanced Features**: Plugin usage → AI agent interaction → complex scenarios

#### 2.2 Multiplayer Interaction Tests
**Target File**: `tests/e2e/test_multiplayer_scenarios.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 15-20 tests

**Test Scenarios**:
- **Multi-player Chat**: Public chat → private messaging → group conversations
- **Shared World Events**: Multiple players interacting with same NPC
- **Concurrent Actions**: Simultaneous player movements and interactions

#### 2.3 AI Agent Workflow Tests
**Target File**: `tests/e2e/test_mcp_agent_workflows.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 15-20 tests

**Test Scenarios**:
- **Agent Lifecycle**: Registration → world entry → interaction → unregistration
- **Agent-Player Interaction**: AI agents chatting with players
- **Agent-NPC Interaction**: AI agents interacting with NPCs
- **Multi-agent Scenarios**: Multiple AI agents in shared environment

---

### 3. ⚡ **Performance Testing** - **PRIORITY: MEDIUM**
**Objective**: Validate system performance under load

#### 3.1 Load Testing
**Target File**: `tests/performance/test_load_performance.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 10-15 tests

**Test Areas**:
- **Concurrent Users**: 10, 50, 100, 500 simultaneous connections
- **Message Throughput**: Chat message processing under load
- **Plugin Performance**: Plugin execution under concurrent requests
- **Database Load**: Database query performance with multiple users

#### 3.2 Memory and Resource Testing
**Target File**: `tests/performance/test_resource_usage.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 8-12 tests

**Test Areas**:
- Memory usage profiling during extended sessions
- Plugin memory cleanup verification
- Database connection pooling efficiency
- WebSocket connection resource management

#### 3.3 Response Time Benchmarks
**Target File**: `tests/performance/test_response_times.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 10-15 tests

**Test Areas**:
- API response time benchmarks
- Chat message delivery latency
- NPC response generation timing
- Plugin execution performance

---

### 4. 🔒 **Security Testing** - **PRIORITY: MEDIUM**
**Objective**: Identify and prevent security vulnerabilities

#### 4.1 Input Validation & Sanitization
**Target File**: `tests/security/test_input_validation.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 15-20 tests

**Test Areas**:
- **SQL Injection**: Database query protection
- **XSS Prevention**: Chat message sanitization
- **Command Injection**: Plugin command validation
- **Path Traversal**: File access security

#### 4.2 Authentication & Authorization
**Target File**: `tests/security/test_auth_security.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 10-15 tests

**Test Areas**:
- Session management security
- User privilege escalation prevention
- API endpoint access control
- MCP agent authentication

#### 4.3 Plugin Security
**Target File**: `tests/security/test_plugin_security.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 8-12 tests

**Test Areas**:
- Plugin sandboxing
- Resource access restrictions
- Malicious plugin detection
- Plugin dependency validation

---

### 5. 🧪 **Functional Testing** - **PRIORITY: MEDIUM**
**Objective**: Verify all features work as specified

#### 5.1 Feature Completeness Tests
**Target File**: `tests/functional/test_feature_completeness.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 25-30 tests

**Test Areas**:
- **Chat Features**: All chat functionality variations
- **NPC Features**: All NPC behavior types and interactions
- **Plugin Features**: All plugin types and capabilities
- **MCP Features**: All AI agent interaction types

#### 5.2 User Interface Tests
**Target File**: `tests/functional/test_ui_functionality.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 20-25 tests

**Test Areas**:
- HuggingFace UI component functionality
- Keyboard control responsiveness
- Interface state management
- Error message display

#### 5.3 Configuration & Settings Tests
**Target File**: `tests/functional/test_configuration.py`
**Estimated Tests**: 10-15 tests

**Test Areas**:
- Game configuration loading
- Plugin configuration management
- Service configuration validation
- Environment-specific settings

---

## 📅 **Implementation Timeline**

### **Phase 1: Integration Testing (Week 1-2)**
- Service-to-service integration tests
- Database integration tests
- Real-time update integration tests
- **Target**: 50-65 new tests

### **Phase 2: End-to-End Testing (Week 3-4)**
- Player journey tests
- Multiplayer scenario tests
- AI agent workflow tests
- **Target**: 50-65 new tests

### **Phase 3: Performance & Security Testing (Week 5-6)**
- Load and stress testing
- Security vulnerability assessment
- Resource usage profiling
- **Target**: 40-55 new tests

### **Phase 4: Functional Testing (Week 7-8)**
- Feature completeness verification
- UI functionality testing
- Configuration testing
- **Target**: 55-70 new tests

---

## 🎯 **Success Metrics**

### **Coverage Targets**
- **Integration Tests**: 70% cross-service interaction coverage
- **End-to-End Tests**: 100% critical user journey coverage
- **Performance Tests**: All major performance benchmarks established
- **Security Tests**: All OWASP top 10 vulnerabilities addressed
- **Functional Tests**: 95% feature completeness coverage

### **Quality Gates**
- All tests must pass before deployment
- Performance benchmarks must meet established thresholds
- Security tests must show no critical vulnerabilities
- Integration tests must validate all service interactions

### **Total Project Test Suite Target**
- **Current**: 159 unit tests (100% passing)
- **Target**: 350-400 total tests across all categories
- **Final Coverage**: 85%+ overall code coverage

---

## 🔧 **Infrastructure Requirements**

### **Test Environment Setup**
- Docker containers for isolated testing
- Test database with sample data
- Mock external services (APIs, third-party integrations)
- Performance monitoring tools

### **CI/CD Integration**
- Automated test execution on code changes
- Performance regression detection
- Security vulnerability scanning
- Test result reporting and metrics

### **Testing Tools & Frameworks**
- **pytest** - Core testing framework
- **pytest-asyncio** - Async testing support
- **pytest-mock** - Mocking capabilities
- **locust** - Load testing
- **bandit** - Security testing
- **coverage.py** - Code coverage analysis

---

## 📋 **Current Legacy Cleanup Status**

### **Archived Legacy Files** ✅
- `test_mcp_service.py.legacy` (36 errors)
- `test_mcp_service_fixed.py.legacy` (29 failures)
- `test_npc_service.py.legacy` (API mismatches)
- `test_player_service.py.legacy` (API mismatches)

### **Active Working Files** ✅
- `test_chat_service.py` (43 tests) ✅
- `test_npc_service_corrected.py` (49 tests) ✅
- `test_plugin_service_final.py` (26 tests) ✅
- `test_mcp_service_corrected.py` (41 tests) ✅

**Result**: Clean test discovery with 159 passing tests, 0 failures

---

*Last Updated: June 8, 2025*  
*Status: Service Layer Unit Tests Complete - Ready for Integration Testing Phase*